EYE - Barclays picks recession scenario winners and losers from the retail sector

2023-05-02 11:01:31 ET

Barclays warned on Tuesday that a product recession could take a deep toll on parts of the retail sector. Analyst Adrienne Yih and team see building risk to a second-half demand recovery.

"For retail specifically, many have guided 1H23 to be weak, with even negative sales, and a recovery in 2H23 as they lap excessively deep promos from the prior year. Of the companies we cover, 46% posted negative y/y sales growth in 4Q22."

Based on the promotional activity tracked by Barclays, the firm believes the notion of broad-based retailer demand improvement in Q1 of 2023 is at risk as well as the forward sales outlook.

With the evidence increasing that a recession could be on hand, Barclays recommends limited exposure to consumer product discretionary and sticking with best-in-class names. As part of its preparation for a recession scenario, downgrades were fired off by Barclays on a number of apparel-related stocks. Canada Goose ( GOOS ), National Vision Holdings ( EYE ), Under Armour ( UAA ), Victoria's Secret ( VSCO ), and Capri Holdings ( CPRI ) were issued downgrades to Equal-weight from Overweight. Meanwhile, FIGS ( FIGS ) was lowered to Underweight from Equal-weight.

Some of the consumer discretionary stocks by Barclays seen as best positioned for relative outperformance during a recession include TJX Companies ( TJX ), Ross Stores ( ROST ), Nike ( NKE ), Dick's Sporting Goods ( DKS ), and Ralph Lauren ( RL ).

With evidence mounting of a 2H23 recession, we recommend limited exposure to consumer product discretionary, sticking with best-in-class names to weather a downturn. Despite being an early cycle sector exiting a recession, we note that a slowing consumer spending environment has historically impacted all retailers.

More on consumer discretionary stocks:

• Sticky Inflation And Potential Implications For The Retail Sector
• View the growth metrics on Nike
• See the valuation metrics on Under Armour
• Check out the consumer discretionary stocks with the highest Seeking Alpha Quant Rating

For further details see: