GOMRF - Rare Earths Outlook 2020: Trade War to Dominate Supply and Demand

Rare earths started the year as the metal that few people outside of the sector knew about but interacted with daily. However, by Q2, the critical metals were top of mind as China considered cutting off US access, causing concern of a supply shortage. 

While the trade war did dominate the news cycle, prices were less volatile than expected, with a spike occurring early in the year before they slipped back and remained steady for the remainder of 2019.

Rare earths, which are used in the high strength magnets found in much of the latest tech, from smartphones to wind turbines and electric vehicles, will remain a primary issue for the resource sector well into the next decade as more countries in the west work to create a supply chain that is less dependent on China.

“Despite the continuous talk by some in the media about China potentially weaponizing its rare earths during trade negotiations with the US, prices of most rare earths have trended lower or stayed fairly flat for most of the year, with few exceptions,” said Luisa Moreno, managing director of Tahuti Global.

Moreno noted that the most in-demand and noteworthy of the rare earths, neodymium and praseodymium, did not sustain the price bump the export scare brought on during the first half of 2019.

“The magnet elements neodymium and praseodymium have also shown weak prices, particularly when comparing the average prices at the first quarter of the year relative to the third and fourth quarters,” she said.

With that said, there were two metals from the group of 17 that did experience price growth throughout the year.

“The only elements that have shown a notable increase in prices were dysprosium (Dy) and terbium (Tb). Both are used in permanent magnet motors for electric vehicles and are significantly less common than neodymium,” Moreno explained. “Dy prices, in particular, increased by 45 percent in Q3 compared to Q1. Dy and Tb prices have weakened in the last quarter of the year, but they are still higher compared to the average first quarter prices.”

Despite the threat of a Chinese export embargo never materializing, the sector still used the opportunity to ramp up discussions of building and strengthening the supply chain to be less reliant on Chinese producers and separators.

“Five, six years ago, 98 percent of the rare earths came from China, and now about 60 percent do,” Mercenary Geologist Mickey Fulp told the Investing News Network (INN). “The west or anywhere outside of China is at least contributing a significant amount of rare earths. The problem once again is all the downstream capability is still concentrated in China.”

The rare earth supply chain is quite complex, comprised of the traditional explorers, developers and miners. However, like other metals such as lithium, there are also several other steps in the processing, separation and refinement of the material before it is an end-use product.

Moreno pointed out, “(The) US is the largest importer of REEs from China by volume, but Japan is actually the largest importer of REE from China by value. The US exports almost as much REE (in content) to China as it imports, although REEs that US exports to China are not refined, is likely a REE mix concentrate from Mountain Pass. The US is likely to continue to export REEs to China in the immediate future.”

Rare earth outlook 2020: Supply diversity key motivator

In late July, the US secretary of defense released a memorandum that determined the domestic production capability for rare earth metals and alloys is essential to national defense.

The government committed to finding ways to strengthen its domestic supply chain.

For analyst and sector watcher Moreno, the US stance, as well as the stance of other nations like Australia and Canada, on developing a robust procurement strategy was the most important news of the year for rare earths.

“A number of agreements have been signed but the actual dollar amounts behind the efforts are not clear,” she said. “For instance, the US has signed rare earth and strategic minerals development agreements with Canada, Australia, Botswana, Botswana, Zambia, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Namibia, Argentina, Peru, Brazil, among others.”

One of the companies that could play a role in building the North American supply chain is Avalon Advanced Materials (TSX:AVL,OTCQB:AVLNF), a diversified technology and battery metals company with several projects in Canada, including a rare earth project in development in the Northwest Territories.

“As Avalon expected, the threat to security of supply of critical minerals attracted a lot mainstream media attention and new interest from the government in helping to establish these new supply chains,” Don Bubar, president and CEO told INN.

“However, considerable investment is required in developing new processing capacity before new primary supply can be turned into the refined products needed by end-users.”

While political attention and promises are good for the news cycle, for explorers, developers and even some producers, it’s more of an issue of putting the money where the talk is.

As Bubar explained, the most challenging aspect of the market for North American companies is raising the capital needed to fund the processes needed for production.

“Most mineral development companies operating in North America are publicly traded and rely on equity markets for raising venture capital,” he said. “For non-exchange traded commodities that lack visibility on pricing, like rare earths, raising capital is challenging. Development companies need to attract strategic investors, including government, that understand the market and the processing challenges.”

The rare earth market is much more opaque than other metals, especially in the area of price transparency, which makes it hard for investors to follow.

Don Lay, CEO of sector junior Medallion Resources (TSXV:MDL,OTC Pink:MLLOF), also sees financing as the most pressing challenge facing companies in the space. He also thinks investors should use this time to educate themselves and find out where they can best invest their money in this developing sector.

“It’s a tricky market, but fascinating, and it will likely be very rewarding over the next few years,” he said. “Australia has a very active REE investment market led by the producer Lynas (ASX:LYC,OTC Pink:LYSCF). But there are several developers with market caps around US$100 million.”

As Lay mentioned, Lynas leads the Australian market and much of the global sector outside of China. The producer came to prominence when Japan invested in its growth to circumvent China’s market dominance following a trade dispute that left the island nation without the critical metals it needed for its rapidly growing technology sector in the early and mid 2000s.

It has been a good year for Lynas, with shares climbing 48 percent year-to-date. The Australian government is looking to capitalize on the rare earth interest as well.

At this year’s International Mining and Resources Conference in Melbourne, Australia, David Grabau, senior investment specialist for resources and energy at Austrade, spoke about the opportunity the sector presented for the continent.

“There’s a whole lot of scope here, and in terms of Australia’s involvement in this subsector, what we’re focusing on is where we think we have some competitive advantage,” he said. “What we would like to see is more consistency in the market so that international financiers and equity investors might be able to play a larger role.”

Rare earth outlook 2020: Collaboration key for sector growth 

Removing opaqueness to entice investors will remain a primary goal of the sector into the new year, as will the need for collaboration across borders.

In mid-November, Australia and the US entered an agreement to work together to build a joint supply chain, and the industry is also working to develop the relationships and capacity needed for a value chain between the countries.

Sector major Lynas is working in conjunction with Texas-based Blue Line to develop a separation facility in the southern state.

Avalon has also benefited from Australian interest in North America, with private Australian company Cheetah Resources (now Vital Metals (ASX:AVL)) joining forces with the Canadian company to develop the Nechalacho project.

Avalon is looking at new ways to produce the metals, which will be in increasing demand over the next 10 years and beyond.

“The potential for economic recovery of rare earths from coal mine wastes and fly ash has been receiving a lot of study in the United States,” he said. “This has accelerated recently with the introduction of new US government initiatives to reduce reliance on China as a source of these critical minerals.”

Kiril Mugerman, CEO of GeoMega Resources (TSXV:GMA,OTC Pink:GOMRF), a rare earth recycling company based in Quebec, wants investors to be cautious in the way they approach the sector, while looking for alternative production streams like recycling as ways to get involved in the market.

He notes that no REE mines were acquired in the last decade, while three projects one of which is bankrupt have entered production in the same period evidencing the difficulty in the sector.

Of the two that have been successful, Mugerman said, “One is a small operation in Africa, and one is a large project in Australia that was bankrolled by Japan and is intent on doubling production and making sure no new mines go into production outside of China. It’s a difficult sector, and with pricing staying at the current level long term, investors should focus on companies who are refining, recycling and producing final product with a low CAPEX.”

Sector spectator Mickey Fulp also agrees that it is difficult to get much production beyond that which Lynas and China control, and new projects have yet to prove their economic viability. However, he is a believer in one US-based rare earth company.

“MP Materials is going to be important in the US,” he said. “Mountain Pass is the best rare earth deposit in the world there is no doubt about that … it has plenty of neodymium and praseodymium, and those are two really important ones.”

Fulp sees MP taking a leading role in the North American narrative as long as it can meet specific conditions.

“Let’s hope they can get their mill running and processing, so the only thing they don’t have is separation capability, which hopefully is going to come from what Lynas is doing in Texas.”

Despite the challenges the rare earth market faced in 2019, those we spoke to remained confident that the growing importance of the critical metals would translate to price growth and prosperity in the long term.

“We think pricing for Nd oxide will keep moving between US$40 and US$50 per kilogram, a healthy range,” said GeoMega’s Mugerman. “Demand growth will keep coming from more usage. More stability and international growth will help bring EV faster to global adaptation.”

Don Bubar of Avalon sees more partnerships leading to a stronger sector.

“The Canadian and American federal governments have also committed to collaborating on establishing supply chains for critical minerals, including rare earths,” he said. “Further news on this initiative should spur continued investment interest in rare earth development companies.”

Heading into the new year, Moreno advises keeping an eye on relations between Washington and Beijing.

“It is possible that the White House may delay any hard trade negotiations with China until after the November 2020 election in the US, to avoid rocking the markets. If that happens, prices may stay stable throughout 2020.”

Don’t forget to follow us @INN_Resource for real-time updates!

Securities Disclosure: I, Georgia Williams, hold no direct investment interest in any company mentioned in this article.

Editorial Disclosure: Medallion Resources is a client of the Investing News Network. This article is not paid-for content.

The Investing News Network does not guarantee the accuracy or thoroughness of the information reported in the interviews it conducts. The opinions expressed in these interviews do not reflect the opinions of the Investing News Network and do not constitute investment advice. All readers are encouraged to perform their own due diligence.