RFEU - Week Ahead: Thumbnail Sketch Of Central Bank Meetings
2023-09-16 09:30:00 ET
Summary
- Central bank meetings dominate the week ahead, with six G10 central banks meeting.
- Brazil and Chile have begun cutting rates, while no G10 central bank appears close to reducing rates.
- The market favors a hawkish hold by the Federal Reserve, while the Norges Bank and Riksbank are likely to signal a hike.
The week ahead is dominated by central bank meetings. Six of the G10 central banks meets. The post-Covid monetary tightening cycle is ending. The start was not synchronized, and neither will be end. It is tempting to think that those that began the tightening cycle early will be among the first to finish.
Among emerging markets, that is true for Brazil and Chile, both of whom have begun cutting rates. And Brazil is likely to deliver the second cut in the new easing cycle, a few hours after the Federal Reserve meeting concludes this week.
No G10 central bank appears to be close to reducing rates, but the tightening cycles seen to be over or within a quarter point of the terminal rate. The UK may be an exception, but even then, the market is not convinced, especially after July's GDP disappointment.
In our age of precision, it is as if we have taken the assessment of the central bank's stance an extra decimal point. It no longer seems to suffice to describe what they did, but it's also an assessment of the forward guidance or thrust. In this context, it means that the market favors a hawkish hold by the Fed, where it stands pat does not rule out additional hikes and revises up growth and perhaps the outlook for policy next year.
On the other hand, the Norges Bank of Norway and the Riksbank of Sweden are understood to have signaled a hike this month (September 21) but are likely to be less hawkish in the forward path of rates that they project. The continued easing of price pressures boosts the chances that Swiss National Bank stand pat.
The euro sold off on the ECB's hikes as it suggested the monetary tightening cycle was over. The SNB may not feel the need to rule out another hike, but the market suspects it is done. The swaps market has about a 75% chance of the Bank of England hiking rates on September 21, even after the economy contracted by 0.5% in July, more than twice as much as economists expected. The key question is whether there is a hike left before the end of the year, and the swaps market sees it as a 50/50 proposition.
Lastly, the Bank of Japan meets on September 22. After adjusting the Yield Curve Control policy to ostensibly allow the 10-year yield to rise to 1.0% at the last meeting, Governor Ueda pointed to a decision on rates toward the end of the year, and it will likely do nothing at the meeting.
Let's dive a little deeper.
Federal Reserve (September 20)
The market never thought a hike this month was likely. The implied odds in the futures market have not gone much above 20% since the July meeting concluded.
Now, after the energy-driven firmness in CPI, PPI, and retail sales, the Fed funds futures imply practically no chance of a hike. The market has downgraded the chances of a November meeting to about 35% (~roughly halved from late August). Still, there is no reason to expect Chair Powell to rule out another hike. That said, the market has shown a tendency to read the statement as hawkish and hear Powell as more dovish. Still, a hawkish hold is likely to be the main takeaway.
The economy's resilience has not only surprised investors but policymakers as well. In March, the median dot was for a 0.4% growth this year. It was raised to 1% in June and could be lifted to 2% now, which would match the median forecast in Bloomberg's survey. The IMF is at 1.8%. The median Fed forecast for the PCE deflator was 3.2%. It stood at 3.0% in June and 3.3% in July. We suspect there is scope for the median to be shaved a little.
The median unemployment rate was at 4.1%. This seems a little high, as it stood at 3.8% in August. Lastly, recall that in June, the median Fed expectation was for two hikes in H2 23 before delivering four cuts in 2024. Here, we expect median dot to be lifted from the 4.625% seen in June to 4.875%, implying one less cut, and not removing the second of the two hikes anticipated in H2 23.
The media will have an opportunity at the press conference following the FOMC meeting to ask the Chair about the rise in oil prices. And even if they do not, we suspect it will become a more salient issue. The Federal Reserve has viewed the rise in oil prices as not necessarily inflationary, but quite the opposite. Higher oil prices could be a relative change in prices, not a general increase in price levels. Higher oil prices act as tax. The more money needed for gasoline and heat/air conditioning, the less there is available for other things/services. The Covid economic crash was an anomaly, but typically a sharp rise in oil prices (doubling) precedes the end of the US business cycle (recession).
Last, we note that despite all the talk of de-dollarization, when the Fed moves, several Middle Eastern central banks will match it, including Saudi Arabia and the UAE, and Hong Kong China's special administrative region.
Bank of England (September 21)
Average weekly earnings accelerated to a new record high in July although other indicators of the labor market slowed. The monthly GDP print for July contracted by 0.5% amid broad-based weakness (industrial production, services, and construction fell). This puts at risk the Bank of England's forecast for Q3 GDP of 0.4%. Seemingly dovish comments by Bank of England Governor Bailey shook the market's confidence that two more hikes would be delivered this year.
The swaps market cut the odds of a quarter-point hike this week to around 70% from a small chance of a 50 bp hike in late August. The market has also trimmed the likelihood of another hike in Q4 to about 30%. It was fully confident as recently as late August.
The UK will report August CPI the day before the BOE meeting. Despite the increase in acceleration of average weekly earnings (to 8.5%, 3-months, year-over-year, July CPI fell by 0.4% bringing the three-month annualized pace to about 1.2% from over 12% in the prior three-month period. The year-over-year pace fell from 10.5% last December to 6.8% in July.
Price pressures may ease a little in August and September before taking a big leg down in October, when last year's 2.0% increase drops out of the 12-month comparison. The Bank of England forecasts CPI to slow to 5% by the end of this year and 2.5% by the end of 2024.
Norges Bank (September 21)
When Norway's central bank lifted the deposit rate by 25 bp to 4.0% in mid-August, it indicated scope for another hike this month. Yet after the unexpectedly large fall in August CPI (-0.8%) and the underlying rate (-0.6%), which excludes energy and adjusts for tax changes, the market has grown a bit skeptical.
The year-over-year increase in Norway's CPI has fallen to 4.8% from 7.0% in January. The underlying rate stood at 6.3% year-over-year in August, down from the 7.0% peak in June. Given the base effect, both the headline and underlying measures of inflation should fall sharply this month. The swaps market is pricing in less than a 20% chance of a hike. The Norwegian economy stagnated in Q2 after expanding by 0.3% in Q1 23 but is off to a stronger start here in Q3. The monthly GDP rose by 0.3% in July.
After the Japanese yen (~-11.3%), the Norwegian krone is the second weakest currency among the G10, depreciating about 8.5% against the dollar so far this year. The krone's weakness seems to run against the idea it is a petro-currency. The price of Brent is up about 8.7% year-to-date. The weakness also seems inconsistent with explanatory models that seek to link a currency with the external account. Norway enjoys a current account surplus of more than 20% of GDP. Its budget surplus is also greater than 20% of GDP.
Riksbank (September 21)
Sweden's Riksbank is a little behind the Norges Bank in the monetary cycle. A quarter-point hike is widely expected at this meeting, which will bring the deposit rate to 4.0%. Another hike in Q4 seems likely. Official comments put an emphasis on the underlying core rate, which uses a fixed interest rate and exclude energy. Although, it has been trending lower at 7.6% in August since peaking at 9.3% in February, it remains unacceptably high. The economy contracted by 0.8% in Q2 after Q1 growth was revised to 0.4% from 0.6%. The Riksbank forecasts that output will decline by 0.5% this year, which may be optimistic.
In addition to the weakness in the manufacturing sector that is a problem among most high-income countries, Sweden also suffers from a dramatic drop in house prices. In nominal terms, Sweden's house prices have fallen by 12% year-over-year. In inflation-adjusted terms, they have fallen by 22% in Q2 year-over-year. This is an important factor depressing consumption, which the Riksbank sees contracting by 2.4% this year.
During the pandemic year of 2020, Sweden's consumption fell by 3.2%. The Swedish krona has depreciated by about 6.6% against the US dollar this year and has fallen to record lows against the euro, where it continues to linger.
Swiss National Bank (September 21)
In Bloomberg's survey, 24 of 27 economists expect the Swiss National Bank to lift the policy rate by 25 bp to 2.00%. The swaps market is less sanguine and appears to have discounted about a 35% probability. The EU harmonized measure of CPI has slipped below 2% in August. The base effect warns that inflation may rise through the end of the year. Last year, the monthly reading was negative for three of the last four months of the year.
The Swiss economy stagnated in Q2 and the median forecast in Bloomberg's survey forecasts a 0.3% growth this quarter. In fact, beginning in Q3 22, the economy has alternated between quarterly expansions of 0.3% and flat activity.
The Swiss franc is strong against the euro. The euro recorded the year's low in late August near CHF0.9515 and approached it after the ECB's dovish hike last week. Recall that last September, it had fallen to nearly CHF0.9400, which it may have traded below once, as the exact low in January 2015 when the SNB moved the euro floor/franc cap is still debated, though some platforms show it spiking to almost CHF0.8500. On balance, we think that SNB can be the big surprise in the week ahead if it stands pat.
Bank of Japan (September 22)
The BOJ may be hoping for a hawkish hold. It is too soon after adjusting, doubling the upper band of the 10-year JGB to 1.0%. Governor Ueda's recent comments point to the end of the year timeframe to re-evaluate the negative policy rate (-0.10%). The market's initial response to the comments was to take the dollar down about 1.5%, which was not enough to cause much consternation. It retraced a little more than half of this month's gains before buyers reemerged and lifted the dollar back above JPY147.00.
The government has already expanded and extended gasoline subsidies through the end of the year. The subsides help dampen the increase in headline CPI. A supplemental budget is likely. The market looks as if it were fishing for the pain threshold of the officials and took the dollar to new highs ahead of the weekend, slightly shy of JPY148. Still, implied volatility remains relatively low (one-month is near 9.2% compared with around 12.5% last September and above 14% when they intervened last October).
Emerging Market Central Banks
Three emerging market central banks look likely to adjust monetary policy.
First, as we noted, Brazil's central bank, which pursued an early and aggressive tightening cycle, is poised to deliver the second 50 bp cut on September 20. It would bring the Selic rate to 12.75%.
The IPCA measure of inflation bottomed in June at 3.16% and rose in July and August to stand at 4.61%. This is primarily a reflection of the base effect as the IPCA fell on a monthly basis last July-September. On an annualized basis, Brazil's IPCA inflation has risen by slightly less than 1.1% over the past three months.
Second, following Turkey's election in May, President Erdogan has turned back toward orthodoxy. The new economics team has hiked the one-week repo rate from 8.5% in May each month since and it now stands at 25%. Given the jump in August inflation to about 59% (from ~47% in July), another hike looks likely. The median forecast in Bloomberg's survey is for a 500 bp hike (to 30%) on September 21.
Third, higher food prices, including rice and vegetables, and a weak peso may spur the Philippines central bank to hike the overnight rate from 6.25%, where it has been since March. Consumer prices, which had fallen from 8.7% in January to 4.7% in July, rose to 5.3% in August. They rose 1.1% in August alone after rising by a cumulative 1.6% in the first seven months of the year. The central bank is believed to have intervened to prevent the dollar from rising above PHP57.0. It has not closed below PHP56.50 for three weeks, giving officials little breathing space. A rate hike could help reinforce the cap.
Editor's Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.
For further details see:
Week Ahead: Thumbnail Sketch Of Central Bank Meetings