HYEM - Why EM Debt Investors Shouldn't Fear The Fed
- We now believe that EM debt could represent a buying opportunity for investors looking to take advantage of higher yields and improved valuations.
- The speed and extent of further monetary tightening in the United States are uncertain, and as a result, there are concerns about the impact of rate hikes on future fixed-income returns.
- We believe the current rate-hiking cycle is unlikely to be different. Most of investors’ legitimate concerns have already played out, with much of the bad news already priced into the asset class.
The speed and extent of further monetary tightening in the United States are uncertain, and as a result, there are concerns about the impact of rate hikes on future fixed-income returns. But we do not believe investors should be concerned, and this may even be a buying opportunity.
In previous posts, we considered five key fears driving concerns about the future returns of EM sovereign debt in light of three previous tightening cycles that occurred during the life of this asset class: 1999 to 2000, 2004 to 2006, and 2015 to 2018.
Although each cycle we analyzed involved unique global economic factors, EM debt returns in the 12 months following the start of a rate-hiking cycle have been strong, as the chart below shows. Double-digit returns of 14.67%, 18.44%, and 10.15% were recorded 12 months after the first rate hike in 1999-2000, 2004-2006, and 2015-2018, respectively. And in each instance, spreads tightened into the hikes.
We believe the current rate-hiking cycle is unlikely to be different. Most of investors' legitimate concerns have already played out, with much of the bad news already priced into the asset class.
In fact, we have already begun to see a significant upward rise in U.S. Treasury yields; EM debt spreads have widened materially; and the starting yield on the J.P. Morgan EMBIGD was already beginning to look attractive as the Fed began hiking. In addition, we have already seen material net outflows from the asset class this year; the U.S. dollar ((USD)) has strengthened to multiyear highs; and positioning is heavy.
In each of the past rate-hiking cycles we examined during the life of this asset class, high-yield EM debt has outperformed investment-grade EM debt in the 12 months following the first Fed rate hike. We expect the current tightening cycle to be no different. The high-yield/investment-grade spread differential is trading at historically wide levels, as the chart below shows.
Also, as noted in the previous section, cash prices are low across the asset class, and the number of bonds trading at distressed levels has already reached an all-time high, with prices of C-rated bonds already averaging in the mid-$30s, which is well below historical recovery levels.
We thus believe it could be compelling to overweight the high-yield sector at the expense of investment-grade bonds that offer less probability-weighted upside, and to seek to take advantage of valuations in distressed credits.
We believe only a very bearish set of circumstances is likely to generate negative returns for investors over the next year. Our analysis suggests it would likely take a combination of the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield rising and EM debt spreads widening substantially for the asset class to generate a negative return.
This is unlikely, in our view, as spreads have tended to widen more than 200 bps on global recession fears (and they have widened nearly 150 bps since last year). If fears about a global recession do materialize, we expect to see a significant drop - rather than a rise - in the 10-year U.S. Treasury yield, which would likely act as a cushion against spread widening.
Our base case is that the U.S. 10-year U.S. Treasury yield stabilizes at around 3% and spreads tighten back to more historical levels. In this case, the asset class could generate compelling returns for EM debt investors over the coming year. And long term, we believe low historical default rates and high recovery values bode well.
Thus, we now believe that EM debt may represent a buying opportunity for investors looking to take advantage of higher yields and improved valuations. Of course, in today's environment, nothing is certain. We remain focused on navigating risks and changing market conditions to identify attractive investment opportunities on behalf of our clients.
Editor's Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.
For further details see:
Why EM Debt Investors Shouldn't Fear The Fed