2024-02-01 04:09:03 ET
Investor anxiety has gripped the financial markets as New York Community Bancorp (NYSE: NYCB) shocked stakeholders by unveiling a surprising loss in its fourth-quarter earnings report.
The unexpected downturn sent NYCB shares plummeting by 40%, sparking concerns about the stability of the institution amidst a volatile banking landscape.
NYCB dividend cut and unexpected loss
New York Community was viewed favourably after it acquired assets from the collapsed Signature Bank and Flagstar Bank in 2023. The acquisition of assets from Signature Bank and Flagstar Bank pushed NYCB’s balance sheet above the $100 billion regulatory threshold, subjecting it to stricter capital and liquidity requirements as a Category IV bank.
However, the disappointing Q4 earnings report has sent shockwaves throughout the stock market with its shares down 38% at press time.
In its Q4 report, NYCB disclosed a loss of $0.27 per share for the quarter, a stark contrast to the anticipated earnings of $0.26 per share. Additionally, the company’s revenue fell short of expectations, registering $886 million compared to the consensus estimate of $929.51 million. It made an unexpected loss of $260 million in Q4, compared to a gain of $164 million the previous year, catching investors off guard, seeing that the loss has wiped out previous gains driven by the acquisition.
The bank has also announced that it has decided to slash dividends by over two-thirds as it aims to bolster its capital reserves and fortify its balance sheet. However, analysts expressed scepticism, noting that the unexpected moves by NYCB, including a substantial provision for loan losses and the dividend cut, was the primary driver for the decline in shares and has also led to a lack of confidence in the bank’s management.
Market reaction and analyst insights
The abrupt downturn in NYCB shares rattled the financial markets, with the KBW Regional Banking Index (.KRX) witnessing a significant 6% drop – its most substantial single-day decline since the collapse of Signature Bank in 2023. The unexpected decline raised concerns about the overall health of regional lenders, with investors expressing worries about the cost of retaining deposits squeezing net interest income (NII), a critical driver of lending profits.
Analysts expressed surprise at NYCB’s unexpected loss and dividend reduction, highlighting concerns over the bank’s risk management processes and profitability outlook.
Deutsche Bank analysts maintained a Buy rating on NYCB stock, acknowledging the bank’s efforts to enhance its risk management practices but also noting the substantial provisions for loan losses. Meanwhile, UBS analysts adopted a more cautious stance, maintaining a Neutral rating and expressing concerns over the challenging results.
RBC Capital analysts echoed similar sentiments, emphasizing the adverse impact of larger-than-expected provisions for credit losses on NYCB’s quarterly performance. The reduction in dividends further underscored the bank’s efforts to fortify its financial position amidst heightened market volatility and regulatory scrutiny.
Implications for the larger US banking sector
Investor jitters were palpable as the Federal Reserve’s decision to leave interest rates unchanged further added to concerns. Higher interest rates, aimed at curbing inflation, have been weighing on regional bank loan profits and the value of securities they hold.
The surprising nature of NYCB’s troubles led traders to reevaluate their positions, with options backed by SPDR S&P regional bank exchange-traded funds seeing increased bearish sentiment. Put options, indicating a bearish view, outnumbered calls 3-to-1, suggesting a more pessimistic outlook.
Moody’s responded to NYCB’s weakened position by placing all long-term and short-term ratings and assessments of the bank and its subsidiary, Flagstar Bank, under review for a downgrade. The rating action was prompted by the bank’s weak earnings, decline in capitalization, and growing reliance on wholesale funding. NYCB’s journey across the $100 billion regulatory threshold was not without challenges, and analysts emphasize the need for banks to be prepared for such milestones, as evident in the market reactions to NYCB’s unexpected financial struggles.
On a broader perspective, the competitive landscape remains intense, with other banks such as Valley National Bancorp (VLY.O), Citizens Financial Group (CFG.N), and Regions Financial Corp (RF.N) also experiencing declines ranging from 4% to 7.8%.
According to Barchart , “US Banks are facing unrealized losses of roughly $685 billion (updated as of Q3). This problem isn’t going away any time soon until the Federal Reserve begins cutting. New York Community Bancorp might be the next victim.”
The post Fears of New York Community Bancorp (NYCB) collapse, plunged 40% post-earnings appeared first on Invezz