LLY - Eli Lilly POINTs Toward Radiopharmaceutical Ambitions

2023-10-03 13:32:22 ET

Summary

• Eli Lilly's acquisition of POINT Biopharma Global strategically boosts its portfolio in radiopharmaceuticals, with immediate late-stage clinical assets and manufacturing capabilities.
• POINT Biopharma's financial health is stable with a 27-month cash runway, but escalating R&D expenses and share dilution raise concerns for scaling.
• Investment Recommendation: Downgrade PNT stock to "Sell." Regulatory uncertainties and the baked-in acquisition premium limit upside, making it prudent to lock in profits now.

Eli Lilly's Acquisition of POINT Biopharma Global

In the ever-shifting landscape of biopharmaceuticals, Eli Lilly's ( LLY ) proposed acquisition of POINT Biopharma Global ( PNT ) continues to signify a well-calibrated blend of clinical and financial ambitions. This move comes as the next logical step since my previous analysis , where I highlighted POINT's pioneering role in radioligand therapy and its robust financial metrics. Eli Lilly's proposed access to POINT's innovative assets, especially in prostate and neuroendocrine tumors, indicates an accelerated route to market transformative therapies. However, the 87% acquisition premium suggests that the stock may have hit its near-term peak, with regulatory hurdles still looming. For current investors, this could signal an opportune moment to secure profits, as the acquisition premium seems largely baked into the stock price.

POINT Biopharma's Q2 Earnings

To begin my analysis, looking at POINT Biopharma's most recent earnings report for Q2 2023, the company generated a revenue of $4.9M compared to zero in the same quarter last year. However, the burn rate is concerning. R&D expenses surged to $31.3M from $20.8M year-over-year, and G&A costs saw an increment to $5.1M from $4.1M. The loss from operations stands at $31.5M, deepening from $24.9M in the prior year. Share dilution is evident, with the weighted average common shares outstanding increasing from 90.1M to 105.7M, diluting existing shareholders.

Financial Health of POINT Biopharma

Turning to POINT Biopharma's balance sheet as of June 30, 2023, the company holds $57.3M in cash and cash equivalents and $365.9M in short-term investments. Adding $11.6M in long-term investments, the total liquid assets amount to $434.8M. The company's current ratio, calculated as total current assets ($432.4M) divided by total current liabilities ($41.2M), stands at 10.5. Over the last six months, POINT Biopharma has incurred a net cash outflow in operating activities of $96.7M, translating to a monthly cash burn of approximately $16.1M. Accordingly, the company's cash runway would be roughly 27 months. It's worth noting that these calculations are based on historical data and may not reflect future performance.

Based on these findings, the probability of the company needing to secure additional financing within the next 12 months appears to be low. With a monthly cash burn rate of $16.1M and a robust cash position, POINT Biopharma has ample liquidity to continue its operations in the medium to long term without requiring immediate external capital. These are my personal observations, and other analysts might interpret the data differently.

Inside Lilly's $1.4 Billion Investment in POINT Biopharma

Eli Lilly is set to purchase POINT Biopharma for a cash consideration of $12.50 per share, culminating in a total transaction worth around $1.4 billion. Remarkably, this valuation is an 87% uptick compared to POINT's market close as of October 2, 2023. The deal's finalization is anticipated by the close of 2023, contingent upon receiving the green light from regulatory bodies, notably the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

From a Lilly perspective, this acquisition is not merely an asset purchase but an infrastructure investment. POINT's 180,000-square-foot radiopharmaceutical manufacturing facility in Indianapolis adds manufacturing heft to Lilly's portfolio. This is a crucial factor for investors to note; owning the means of production in a field as specialized as radiopharmaceuticals gives Lilly a leg up in both speed-to-market and cost control.

For POINT investors, the lucrative 87% premium offers an attractive exit, but it's worth noting the strategic fit. The acquisition includes POINT's late-stage clinical assets, specifically targeting prostate and neuroendocrine tumors, along with additional early-stage programs. This rich pipeline likely contributed to the premium price, elevating the value for current shareholders while suggesting that POINT's assets are considered high value by industry standards.

In sum, Lilly's acquisition of POINT is a multi-faceted strategic move, diving deeper into the growing field of radiopharmaceuticals with immediate access to late-stage clinical assets and a robust manufacturing facility. POINT shareholders get a lucrative offer and the satisfaction of seeing their company's innovations likely accelerated by Lilly's larger resource pool. However, regulatory approvals are the looming variable that could impact the transaction's timing and ultimate success.

My Analysis & Recommendation

In conclusion, the acquisition deal between Eli Lilly and POINT Biopharma appears advantageous for both parties involved. For Eli Lilly, the addition of POINT's specialized radiopharmaceutical manufacturing facility and late-stage clinical assets serve as a robust value proposition, optimizing their speed-to-market and cost efficiencies in an ever-competitive sector. This deal expands Lilly's strategic foothold into a specialty arena, implying potential for above-market growth rates in the long term.

For POINT shareholders, the 87% premium is an immediate win, and it suggests that the intrinsic value of POINT's pipeline and manufacturing capabilities are not only recognized but also highly valued by an industry behemoth. Yet, shareholders should be cautious regarding regulatory approvals, specifically from the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. While a failure in regulatory approval could stall or derail the transaction, given the specialized nature of POINT's business, alternative acquirers are not easily found, potentially leading to stock price volatility.

Investors should particularly watch for any flags during the regulatory review process, such as unmet safety standards or integration issues, which could not only delay but potentially scuttle the deal. Given that POINT's cash runway is about 27 months, they are not in immediate need for a lifeline, but the increased burn rate indicates a critical need for scaling, which Lilly can provide.

As for an investment recommendation, despite the attractive premium, I would downgrade POINT to a "Sell." The risk-to-reward ratio at this juncture leans toward locking in profits. Any regulatory hurdles or delays could expose investors to downside risk, and given the already substantial premium on the table, the upside appears limited.

This is a rare instance where the stars align almost perfectly for both acquiring and acquired companies. However, the closing of this deal remains a coin flip until regulatory approvals come through. Until then, it may be prudent for POINT investors to mitigate risks and secure profits.

Risks to Thesis

Given my "Sell" recommendation, several risks could contradict this stance.

• Underestimation of Synergistic Value: The strategic fit between Eli Lilly and POINT could offer higher value than assumed, particularly in accelerating pipeline products.

• Regulatory Approval Overemphasized: I've highlighted regulatory risks, but the specialization of POINT's radiopharmaceutical assets might make approval more likely than general pharma deals.

• Underestimated Cash Runway: POINT's 27-month cash runway could give them more leeway in either renegotiating terms or surviving should the deal fall through.

• Activist Investors or Counter-bids: POINT's strong balance sheet and strategic assets could attract other bidders or activist investors, potentially driving the share price above Lilly's offer.

• Post-Acquisition Shareholder Benefits: Current POINT shareholders might receive additional incentives, such as special dividends or preferential terms in future Lilly ventures, which are currently unaccounted for.

• Opportunity Cost: By selling, investors may miss out on future growth catalyzed by the acquisition, especially if Lilly can effectively integrate and optimize POINT's assets.

For further details see: