2024-01-04 18:40:08 ET
Summary
- Affirm Holdings, Inc.'s business model has improved, leading to a surge in stock value, but the market is too bullish.
- The company has announced big deals in the Buy Now, Pay Later space, but investors should be cautious as large retailers don't like to give up profits.
- Affirm Holdings' revenue less transaction costs is expected to slump in the December quarter, and the company faces challenges in matching gross revenue growth with bottom line numbers.
- Affirm stock is too expensive at over 15x net revenues considering the limited profits.
Affirm Holdings, Inc. ( AFRM ) has seen the business model improving heading into the stock surge during the last couple of months of 2023. The market appears to have gotten far too bullish on the investment story due to the addition of a new large retailer. My investment thesis is more Bearish on the stock following the surge to over $40 now.
Source: Finviz
Big Deals
Affirm has announced some big deals in the buy now, pay later ("BNPL") space, but investors should always have raised eyebrows on these deals. Large retailers like Amazon ( AMZN ) and Walmart ( WMT ) don't necessarily choose partners in order to watch profits walk out the door.
The fintech guided to FQ2'24 revenue in the $500+ million range for strong growth approaching 30%, with consensus estimates up at $518 million. The problem is that revenue less transaction costs ((RLTC)) is expected to slump to $200 million, or below, in the December quarter.
The problem facing Affirm is that this key category isn't exactly growing to match the gross revenues. Affirm posted quarterly RLTC of ~$182 million for the last 2 years, and the current guidance has FQ2 headed back in that direction.
A big part of the problem is the ~$100 million in provisions costs in FQ1 due somewhat to the initial CECL charge. The provision charges are surging, with higher GMV leading to the net revenue metrics basically flatlining.
Affirm reported FQ1'24 RLTC of just 3.8% of GMV, down from 4.2% in the prior FQ1. The higher hidden transactions costs from funding to provisions isn't reflected in the stock surging due to headline revenue growth.
Since announcing the FQ1'24 earrings report in early November, Affirm has announced expanded plans with self-checkout at Walmart stores and teamed up with Google Pay for more flexible options for shoppers. The fintech had just announced the additional BNPL option for business customers on Amazon prior to the quarterly report.
The company expects GMV to jump to $50 billion in the near term from a rate in the $25 billion range now. The stock appears to already factor in such growth.
Priced For GMV Growth
Affirm only has $800 million in RLTC with the stock now worth $13 billion. If the company hits the GMV target, the RLTC amount only hits up to $1.5 billion for a stock worth $13 billion already.
The fintech moving more into Walmart self-checkout could face higher delinquencies in the year ahead. The biggest risk is that more customers are stretched in 2024, and a push into more BNPL transactions aren't necessarily good for business.
The company only guided to a less than 5% adjusted operating margin for FQ2. With Affirm approaching $7 billion in GMV for the December quarter, the company is no longer a small operation with unlimited growth ahead. Affirm needs to start generating profits and prove the Amazon and Walmart deals are financially rewarding, not just positive for gross revenues.
Affirm has guided to FY24 shares outstanding of 311 million, with stock-based compensation expenses topping $112 million in FQ1 alone. The company won't have an adjusted profit without excluding SBC.
In essence, Affirm isn't profitable enough to cover non-cash compensation and, of course, risks exist for higher provision expenses in an actual recession. The BNPL business is more complicated than purely signing up new payment platforms driving growth. The dynamics of new deals may not be favorable to the company, and the costs might rise in order to acquire new customers leading to the current position where RLTC isn't growing at a clip to match gross revenues.
Takeaway
The key investor takeaway is that Affirm Holdings, Inc. shares are not accurately priced based on the net revenues, which include substantial costs for funding BNPL loans and provisions for credit losses. The fintech still has a very small adjusted operating margin and investors should've used the recent rally to $50 to unload a stock once trading below $10 during 2023.
For further details see:
Affirm: Too Far, Too Fast